Discover the 17 Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island
Anna Maria Island, located off the west coast of Florida near Tampa Bay, is a popular vacation destination known for its sugar sand beaches and crystal clear waters. In addition to the many activities and attractions available on the island, it’s also home to some of the best seafood restaurants in the state.
From high-end dining to laid-back seaside eateries, there’s something for every taste and budget on Anna Maria Island. In this article, we’ll explore the top seafood restaurants on the island and give you a taste of what each one has to offer. Whether you’re visiting the island or just looking for a new seafood spot to try, these restaurants are sure to satisfy your cravings.
Contact: +1 941-779-9151
Address: 2519 Gulf Drive N. , Bradenton Beach, FL, United States, Florida
Sharky’s Seagrill is a top choice for seafood lovers visiting Anna Maria Island. The restaurant’s menu is seafood-centric, with a wide variety of options ranging from oysters and clams to grilled fish and lobster.
One of the highlights of Sharky’s Seagrill is the seafood boil, which allows you to choose your own seafood and seasoning to be cooked in a giant pot and served with corn and potatoes. In addition to seafood, Sharky’s Seagrill also offers burgers, sandwiches, and salads for those looking for something a little different. The drink menu includes a variety of cocktails, beers, and wines to pair with your meal.
One of the best parts of Sharky’s Seagrill is the outdoor seating area with a view of the water. You can enjoy your meal while taking in the beautiful surroundings of Anna Maria Island. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner daily, with live music events on select nights.
Contact: +1 941-778-1919
Address: 900 Gulf Dr N Bradenton Beach, FL 34217
If you’re looking to relax and soak up the laid-back island atmosphere, Kokonut Hut is the perfect choice. Located on the north end of Anna Maria Island, this restaurant has a tropical vibe with tiki huts and palm trees surrounding the outdoor seating area.
The menu at Kokonut Hut is inspired by island flavors, with a focus on seafood dishes like lobster rolls and fish tacos. The tiki drinks are a must-try, with options like tropical cocktails and frozen daiquiris.
In addition to the delicious food and drinks, Kokonut Hut also hosts live music events on select nights. You can enjoy your meal while listening to island-inspired tunes in a relaxed, casual setting.
Wicked Cantina(Mexican Restuarant)
Contact: +1 941-706-2395
Address: 1603 N. Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL, United States, Florida
Wicked Cantina is a popular spot on Anna Maria Island for those looking for Mexican-inspired cuisine and drinks. The menu features a variety of tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and other dishes, as well as a selection of margaritas and other cocktails. Some of the highlights at Wicked Cantina include the fish tacos and the pineapple habanero margarita.
The outdoor seating area at Wicked Cantina is a great spot to enjoy your meal, with plenty of shade and a casual atmosphere. The restaurant also hosts live music events on select nights, adding to the fun and energetic vibe.
Bridge Street Bistro(Seafood Restaurant)
Contact: +1 941-782-1122
Address: 111 Gulf Dr S, Bradenton Beach, FL, United States, Florida
Bridge Street Bistro is a fine dining restaurant that offers upscale service and an extensive wine list. The restaurant is located in Bradenton Beach, an island town that is known for its romantic atmosphere.
The atmosphere at Bridge Street Bistro is one of romance and elegance, with dark wood accents and candlelit tables. The menu features locally sourced ingredients from the region, including fresh seafood dishes as well as land-based options.
Bridge Street Bistro has an extensive wine list, with over 100 different wines available by the bottle or glass. If you’re looking for a romantic date night spot on Anna Maria Island, Bridge Street Bistro is sure to impress!
Contact: +1 910-256-4519
Address: 1414 Airlie Rd, Wrightsville Beach, NC, United States, North Carolina
The Bridge Tender is a waterfront restaurant on Anna Maria Island, with views of the bay and a menu that’s full of fresh, local seafood. The restaurant is known for its relaxed and casual atmosphere and live music events, which take place outside on the deck and inside in the bar area.
The menu focuses on local craft beers, seasonal produce and ingredients, and fresh seafood from the Gulf of Mexico. Standout dishes include fish tacos made with grouper or mahi-mahi, shrimp scampi over pasta with garlic breadcrumbs, and ceviche made with Florida Keys rock shrimp.
The Bridge Tender also offers outdoor seating options overlooking the water, where you can enjoy your meal while listening to live music performances by local artists.
Anna Maria Oyster Bar(Seafood Restaurant)
Anna Maria Oyster Bar is a casual, yet sophisticated restaurant located on Anna Maria Island. The menu focuses on fresh seafood and offers a wide range of options for oysters, seafood boils, fish, and more.
The atmosphere at Anna Maria Oyster Bar is casual, with an emphasis on having fun—there’s live music every Friday night! Outdoor seating is also available, so you can enjoy the breeze as you enjoy your meal.
A few popular dishes include the oysters Rockefeller appetizer and the grilled grouper sandwich. You’ll find a variety of seafood boils as well, including shrimp boil with sausage andouille sausage, or crab boil with corn on the cob.
Contact: +1 941-778-0771
Address: 201 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach, FL, United States, Florida
Oma’s Pizza is a family-friendly restaurant on Anna Maria Island that has been serving up delicious Italian-inspired dishes since the 70s. The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable, making it the perfect place to enjoy a meal with family or friends.
The menu includes a wide range of pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches. Popular dishes include their famous calzone, made fresh to order; crispy calamari; and a wide range of delicious pizzas like the Margarita and Hawaiian.
They offer outdoor seating year-round, so you can dine al fresco while enjoying live music events hosted by local musicians.
Coquina Beach Cafe
Contact: +1 941-778-4757
Coquina Beach Cafe is the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal while watching the sun set over the water. The menu highlights include sandwiches, breakfast and lunch specials, smoothies, and fresh seafood dishes. Be sure to try the coconut shrimp or the crab cake sandwich!
If you’re looking for a great view of the water, Coquina Beach Cafe has outdoor seating options with a view of the Gulf of Mexico. There is also an indoor area with tables, booths, and bar seating for those who want to stay warm during colder months or rainy days.
The casual atmosphere at Coquina Beach Cafe makes it great for any occasion, from leisurely weekend brunches with friends to family dinners in between beach trips!
Contact: +1 941-778-5788
Address: 5346 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach, FL, United States, Florida
Hurricane Hanks is one of the most popular restaurants on Anna Maria Island. The laid-back, tropical atmosphere is the perfect place to kick back with a tiki drink and enjoy some live music while you dig into some fresh seafood.
The menu at Hurricane Hanks is focused on fresh seafood and tiki drinks. You’ll find a wide selection of fish and shellfish, as well as creative preparations like grilled octopus, grilled salmon with mango salsa verde, and shrimp kebabs served with coconut rice.
Hurricane Hanks also offers an extensive wine list featuring many local wines from Florida wineries, as well as an impressive selection of craft beers from around the world.
Freckled Fin(Irish Pub)
Contact: +1 941-251-3930
Address: 5337 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach, FL, United States, 34217
The Freckled Fin is a great place to grab a bite to eat in the heart of Anna Maria Island. The laid-back atmosphere and seafood-focused menu make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
The Freckled Fin serves up some of the best burgers on the island, but what really makes them stand out is their oyster selection. They have an impressive list of oysters from all over the world available by the dozen or half-dozen, as well as single orders if you’re just looking for something small. You can even get them raw!
If you’re looking for a place to relax with live music, stop by The Freckled Fin on Thursday nights for their local band jam session. The restaurant has plenty of outdoor seating options, so you can enjoy your meal while soaking up some sun.
The Feast Restaurant
Contact: +1 941-778-5092
Address: 5406 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, Anna Maria Island, FL 34217-1763
The Feast is a romantic restaurant with an upscale and modern atmosphere. The menu offers a wide variety of options, including seafood and steak, as well as sushi. If you are looking to impress your date, this is definitely the place!
The Feast specializes in fresh seafood, with everything from crab cakes to lobster tail. The menu also features steaks and chicken dishes, as well as vegetarian options for those who don’t eat meat. If you are looking for something light, there are plenty of salads on the menu as well.
If you’re not in the mood for dinner, stop by for brunch or lunch instead! The brunch menu includes eggs benedict, breakfast burritos, pancakes and French toast.
For lunch there are sandwiches like a grilled chicken sandwich with avocado slices or a turkey club sandwich topped with crisp bacon slices served on whole wheat bread along with fries or chips plus soup or salad if desired.
Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe
Contact: +1 941-778-0784
Address: 4000 Gulf Drive Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe is a casual restaurant with a beachfront setting, located on the north end of Anna Maria Island. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with a view of the water from inside and out.
The menu at Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe features breakfast items like breakfast sandwiches and smoothies, as well as lunch items like sandwiches and salads. For those looking for something sweet after lunch or dinner, there are ice cream flavors to choose from at an outdoor ice cream stand next door.
Guests can sit outside at picnic tables or indoor tables that overlook the water or street.
Contact: +1 941-896-8033
Ugly Grouper, located on the main strip of Anna Maria Island, is a laid-back restaurant that specializes in seafood. The menu focuses on oysters and grouper sandwiches, with plenty of other options to choose from as well. The atmosphere is casual and fun—perfect for a casual dinner or lunch with friends.
For those who want to enjoy their meal al fresco, Ugly Grouper has two different patios where you can sit back and relax while enjoying live music events or people-watching.
North Shore Cafe
Contact: +1 941-900-2671
Address: 304 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL, United States, Florida
North Shore Cafe is the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat on Anna Maria Island. The atmosphere is laid-back and the menu is diverse, featuring sandwiches, seafood entrees, and more. If you’re looking for something light, try their seafood salad or one of their signature sandwiches, the shrimp melt is a local favorite!
If you’re looking for something heartier, North Shore Cafe has plenty of options for you as well. Their seafood pasta dish is made with fresh Gulf shrimp and local vegetables in a creamy sauce that comes with garlic bread or French bread on the side. You can also order grouper tacos or grilled mahi mahi sandwiches if you’re not in the mood for pasta.
North Shore Cafe frequently hosts live music events and outdoor seating options are available during these events so you can enjoy some tunes while relaxing under palm trees with views of beautiful Sarasota Bay.
Contact: +1 941-567-4056
Address: 9701 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL, United States, Florida
Slim’s Place is the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with your family, friends, and loved ones. The atmosphere is island-inspired, with a large outdoor patio area where you can sit and enjoy the sights and sounds of Anna Maria Island.
Slim’s offers classic American dishes such as burgers, seafood platters, salads, and more. Their menu highlights include shrimp tacos and their signature “slims” burger—a juicy burger patty topped with bacon, cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion rings and pickles on a sesame seed bun.
Slim’s also offers live music events several times per week where you can enjoy great tunes while you eat!
SandBar Tiki & Grille
Contact: +1 941-460-8280
Address: 1975 Beach Rd, Englewood, FL, United States, Florida
The Sandbar is a laid-back restaurant that serves up fresh seafood in an atmosphere that’s relaxed and affordable. They have a full bar and plenty of seating options, including outdoor patio decks with views of the water.
Their menu is focused on seafood, with several popular dishes including oysters and grouper sandwiches. They also have live music events several nights per week, which gives you an opportunity to enjoy your meal while listening to some tunes.
Rod N’ Reel Pier
Contact: +1 941-778-1885
Address: 8730 Gulf Drive North in Bradenton Beach, FL 34217
Rod N’ Reel Pier is a seafood-centric restaurant located on the waterfront in Bradenton Beach. The restaurant offers an extensive menu of fresh, flavorful dishes that showcase the bounty of the Gulf of Mexico and Florida’s waterways.
The menu features a variety of fried seafood, including shrimp, oysters, and catfish, as well as platters with a mix of fried and grilled seafood. Rod N’ Reel Pier also offers daily lunch specials that feature a choice of two sides for $8.95. There are also several vegetarian options available daily.
At Rod N’ Reel Pier, you can enjoy your meal while sitting outdoors with views of the water or listening to live music at the bar inside. The restaurant has been operating since 1963 and is located on the historic Anna Maria Island at 8730 Gulf Drive North in Bradenton Beach, FL 34217
Wrapping up on the Best Anna Maria Island Restaurants
Anna Maria Island is home to a diverse range of restaurants, offering something for every taste and budget. From high-end dining at Beach Bistro to laid-back seafood at Sharky’s Seagrill, there’s a restaurant for every occasion.
If you’re looking for a romantic date night spot, Beach Bistro and The Feast are excellent choices, offering fine dining and extensive wine lists in a romantic setting. For a more casual, family-friendly option, Kokonut Hut and Anna Maria Oyster Bar are great choices with island-inspired menus and a laid-back atmosphere.
No matter what type of restaurant you’re looking for, Anna Maria Island has something for everyone. Whether you’re a seafood lover, a Mexican food fan, or just looking for a casual spot to grab a drink and a bite to eat, you’ll find it on Anna Maria Island. So come and explore the diverse dining options available on this beautiful island, and discover your new favorite restaurant.